| HOME | HELP | E-MAIL ALERTS | SEARCH |
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
PEDIATRICS Vol. 107 No. 4 April 2001, pp. 799-803
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Over the past decade, there has been a dramatic increase in the population of juvenile offenders in the United States. Juveniles detained or confined in correctional care facilities have been shown to have numerous health problems. Such conditions may have existed before incarceration; may be closely associated with legal problems; may have resulted from parental neglect, mental health disorders, or physical, drug, or sexual abuse; or may develop within the institutional environment. Delinquent youths are often disenfranchised from traditional health care services in the community. For these adolescents, health care provided through correctional services may be their major source of health services. Pediatricians and correctional health care systems have an opportunity and responsibility to help improve the health of this underserved and vulnerable group of adolescents.
Epidemiologic Factors
A congressionally mandated study released in 1994 reported that
yearly admissions to juvenile correctional facilities reached almost
690 000 in 1990.1 These facilities included short-term
(awaiting adjudication and placement) detention and reception centers
and long-term (postadjudication and placement) training schools and
ranches. Juveniles discharged from correctional facilities in 1990 spent an average of 15 days in short-term detention centers and 32 weeks in long-term training schools.1 In 1996, US courts
with juvenile jurisdiction handled an estimated 1.8 million cases in
which the juvenile was charged with a delinquency offense (an offense
for which an adult could be prosecuted in criminal court). This was a
49% increase, compared with the number of cases handled by juvenile
courts in 1987. Nationally in 1997, 368 juveniles were in custody for
every 100 000 in the population. On October 29, 1997, juvenile
residential facilities held 105 790 delinquent juveniles. Public
facilities housed 76 335 individuals, and private facilities held 29 455.2 The number of offenders younger than 18 years
admitted to adult state prisons has more than doubled from 3400 in 1985 to 7400 in 1997, consistently representing about 2% of new admissions in each of the 13 years.3
Gender demographics of the juvenile population arrested are changing.
In 1996, 1 in 4 juveniles arrested was female. Increases in the
percentages of arrests between 1992 and 1996 were greater for juvenile
females than for juvenile males in most offense categories, including
violent crimes, property crimes, weapon offenses, and drug abuse
violations.4 In 1997, there were 748 000 arrests of
females younger than 18 years representing 26% of all juvenile arrests
that year.5 However, the vast majority (86%) of
individuals detained in residential facilities are males.2
Black and Hispanic youths account for 6 in 10 juveniles held in
residential facilities. Compared with their proportion in the
population, black juveniles are overrepresented at all stages of the
juvenile justice system. Although they comprise only about 15% of the
US population between 10 and 17 years old, they account for
approximately 45% of the population in detention and residential facilities. On October 29, 1997, for every 100 000 non-Hispanic black
juveniles in the population, 1018 were in a residential placement
facility. For Hispanic juveniles, the rate was 515, and for
non-Hispanic whites, it was 204.2 The reasons for this
overrepresentation of youths of color remain unclear but may relate to
factors such as socioeconomic status or racial prejudices.
The rate of recidivism is high in juvenile correctional care
facilities. Approximately 40% of adolescents appearing in juvenile court are repeat offenders. Repeat offenders tend to have committed more serious crimes and are younger at the time of their first offense
than are first offenders.4
Adolescents entering correctional care facilities may be at higher
risk than unincarcerated youths for certain problems that may affect
their general health, including: 1) sexually transmitted diseases
(STDs) and drug use and abuse; 2) issues regarding pregnancy and
parenting; 3) human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection; and 4)
preexisting mental health disorders.
Medical Conditions A landmark report published in 1980 documented medical problems in
46% of incarcerated youths entering correctional care
facilities.6 These problems included conditions occurring
in any population of youth, such as asthma, hypertension, acne, and
diabetes. Conditions occurring at a greater rate in incarcerated than
in unincarcerated youth included a 7% prevalence of tuberculosis
(confirmed by positive results of skin testing) and a 90% prevalence
of dental caries or missing, fractured, or infected
teeth.6 In a more recent study, 10% of juveniles admitted
to a short-term detention facility had significant medical problems
(excluding drug and alcohol abuse or uncomplicated STDs) that, if left
untreated, could have a major effect on the growth and day-to-day
function of the juvenile. The most commonly diagnosed problems were
asthma, orthopedic problems, and otolaryngologic conditions. Only one third of the detainees examined had a regular source of medical care,
and only about one fifth had a private physician. More than half of the
families of adolescents with a preexisting medical problem seemed to be
unable or unwilling to assist in ensuring that the adolescent receive
proper medical care after release.7
STDs
Adolescents in correctional care facilities report having become
involved in sexual behavior at earlier ages and having had greater
rates of STDs than do nondelinquent adolescents.8 Two
recent studies of adolescent males in detention centers substantiated previously documented findings of high rates of STDs in this
population. In one study,9 evidence of at least 1 current
STD was found in 15% of male detainees, and 34% of male detainees had
a history or current evidence of at least 1 STD. Detainees reported
frequent sexual and drug use behaviors.8 In another
study,10 an STD was identified in 12% of male detainees
screened at time of admission to a detention facility. In this group,
more than 50% of the gonorrheal infections and 90% of the chlamydial
infections identified were asymptomatic and detectable only by
screening. The entire population of screened detainees reported
initiating sexual intercourse at an early age (median, 13 years),
having numerous sexual partners (median, 8 partners), and
inconsistently using condoms (only 37% reported always using a
condom).10
A study published in 1990 documented high rates of cervicitis,
vaginitis, and complaints of vaginal discharge in female juvenile correctional populations.11 In a study published in 1998 that used urine-based DNA amplification tests to identify unsuspected
Neisseria gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia trachomatis
infections in detained females at the time of their initial medical
screening, it was determined that C trachomatis infection
existed in 28%, and N gonorrhoeae was present in
13%.12 Overall, 33% of adolescent females evaluated had
positive test results for one or both infections.12
Additionally, reports from Chicago and San Francisco have confirmed the
existence of high rates of STDs among incarcerated
females.13
Pregnancy and Parenthood
As the number of females entering the juvenile justice system
increases, the number who may be pregnant increases. Approximately 6%
of adult women entering prison are pregnant.14
Corresponding data are not available for adolescents. However, a
national survey involving juvenile facilities found that approximately two thirds of 261 correctional facilities housed between 1 and 5 pregnant adolescents on any given day.15 Only about one
third (31%) of responding correctional facilities provide prenatal
services, and only 30% provide parenting classes.15
One quarter of juvenile male detainees have fathered a pregnancy, and
40% of the detainees who are fathers report responsibility for more
than 1 pregnancy.16 A majority of respondents believed
that fathering a child would be desirable, that they would be capable
of being a father to a child, and that they could be responsible for
the child and mother.16 In another study of adolescent
detainees, fathers were more likely than nonfathers and blacks were
more likely than non-Hispanic whites to report that they, their
parents, and their friends would be pleased if they were to father a
child.7
HIV Infection
At the present time, few cases of HIV infection or acquired
immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) are being identified in juvenile correctional facilities. Results of a 1994 National Institute of
Justice and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention survey reported
a cumulative total of 60 incarcerated juveniles (50 boys and 10 girls)
with known AIDS in 73 state and city or county correctional care
systems that responded.17 Similarly, the rate of HIV
seropositivity among confined juveniles seems to be low. Multiple
states have reported far less than a 1% prevalence rate of
seropositivity for HIV among incoming screened juveniles.17 Despite these data, the population of
juvenile detainees is at high risk for developing HIV infection or AIDS
in the future because of high rates of risk-taking behaviors, including
drug use, initiation of sexual intercourse at a young age, having
multiple sexual partners, and inconsistent use of
condoms.8
Preexisting Mental Health Conditions
Mental health problems, predominantly
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, conduct disorder,
oppositional-defiant disorder, and depression, have been found to be
common among incarcerated youths. In 1992, a report reviewing the
mental health needs of youth in the juvenile justice system documented
the following18: 1) at least 20% and perhaps as many as
60% could be diagnosed as having a conduct disorder; 2)
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder may exist in up to 50%; 3)
affective disorders may exist in between 32% and 78%; 4) between 2%
and 17% had a personality disorder; 5) previous suicide attempts
occurred in up to 28%; and 6) psychotic disorders existed in between
1% and 6%. This study also reported that higher rates of psychiatric
hospitalizations occur in juvenile offenders than in the general
population of adolescents. Inpatient psychiatric hospitalization rates
before detention ranged from 12% to 26%. In addition, juveniles
reported previous outpatient contacts or treatment at rates ranging
from 38% to 66%.18 A high rate of posttraumatic stress
disorder in incarcerated juveniles also has been demonstrated in more
recent research.19 The broad prevalence ranges of many of
these mental health diagnoses among juveniles in correctional care
systems may reflect a lack of consistent and comprehensive
evaluations, the variety of settings, or different populations (eg,
male or female, urban or rural).
Many reports have documented that a large percentage of delinquent
youths have experienced significant emotional or physical trauma before
admission to a correctional care facility. Children involved in the
juvenile justice system are more likely to have a history of child
abuse and neglect than those in the general population. Rates of abuse
and neglect have consistently ranged between 25% and 31% of the
incarcerated juvenile population.18
The prevalence of mental retardation among juveniles has consistently
been reported as between 7% and 15%. The rate of learning disabilities and specific developmental disorders that exist among juvenile offenders ranges from 17% to 53%.18 These may
be gross underestimates or overestimates, because most mentally
retarded adolescents do not receive appropriate evaluations by the
juvenile justice system unless or until they have committed the most
serious or violent offenses.
Handgun Ownership
The risk of violent death among youth who have been incarcerated
previously is 76-fold greater than that in the general
population.20 A study of urban high school youths showed
that handgun ownership was highest in youth reporting participation in
criminal behavior.21 Another study22 of
juvenile detainees reported handgun ownership by almost 60% of
respondents. Adolescents who often heard gunfire in their neighborhoods reported rates of handgun ownership of almost twice the rate for other
youth. Almost 50% of detainees and 68% of handgun owners reported
shooting at another person. Of the detainees, 78% reported having been
threatened by someone with a weapon. Perceived improved personal safety
far exceeded recreational reasons as the motivation for handgun
ownership (52% vs 4%).22
Substance Use
Since 1990, the Drug Use Forecasting program conducted by the
National Institute of Justice has shown an increase in illicit drug use
(alcohol use not included) by detainees or arrestees at almost all
sites in the 12 jurisdictions they evaluate in the United
States.23 The rate of juveniles with positive test results
for at least 1 drug ranged from 19% to 58% in 1995. The Drug Use
Forecasting program also found that boys arrested for drug offenses
(sales or possession) had the highest rate of positive drug test
results, compared with youth arrested for other types of
crimes.23 A high rate of drug use also was found among
youth who committed violent, property, and other
crimes.23,24
Juveniles acquire a range of health care problems during the
period of confinement. In one study,25 almost 60% of boys
and 35% of girls in a juvenile correctional care facility required
care for an injury acquired during incarceration. Almost half of these
injuries were associated with recreational or miscellaneous causes,
whereas 20% were associated with fighting, 13% were accidentally
self-inflicted, and 9% were intentionally self-inflicted.25
The high rate of mental health disorders among juveniles is associated
with a high rate of suicide and suicide attempts during incarceration.26 The risk of suicide is especially great
for youths detained in adult jails or lockups and for youths with a
history of psychiatric illnesses.27 A 1984 survey on
health services for juveniles found that approximately 16% of
facilities reported at least 1 death during the preceding 5 years and
that approximately 67% of those deaths were suicides.28
Other common medical problems within the confined juvenile population
include contagious diseases, somatic complaints, menstrual disorders,
and skin problems.6,29 In addition, youths may be victims
of physical and sexual abuse perpetrated by other inmates or staff
while incarcerated. Such incidents may result from overcrowding, poor
supervision or behavioral management, excessive use of restraints or
isolation, or the stress of confinement.11
Most funds used to pay for correctional health care services are
derived from the same budget pool as those for operating the
correctional institution. Other sources of revenue include separate
funds from county or state health departments, grants for pilot
projects, and reimbursement for services provided. Federal guidelines
prohibit the portion of Medicaid that comes from the federal government
to be used for health services within a correctional facility. However,
some states have been able to use state Medicaid funds to provide
services to adolescents awaiting adjudication or for inpatient
services.
Since 1973, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has published
policy statements about health care for correctional care facilities.30,31 The AAP is 1 of more than 30 organizations represented on the Board of Directors of the National
Commission on Correctional Health Care, a not-for-profit organization
that comprises representatives from the fields of corrections, law, law
enforcement, and medical, dental, and mental health care. Its primary
purpose is to work with correctional facilities to assist in improving
their systems for providing health care. The commission publishes
national standards for correctional health services, offers a voluntary
accreditation program,32,33 and publishes official
position statements.
The standards are categorized into the following 6 sections that
provide guidelines and an explanation for implementation of each of the
approximately 70 standards: 1) administration; 2) managing a safe and
healthy environment; 3) personnel; 4) care and treatment; 5) health
records; and 6) medical-legal issues. An updated Standards of
Services in Juvenile Detention and Confinement Facilities is
available from the Commission.32
![]()
SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM
![]()
HEALTH CONDITIONS EXISTING BEFORE INCARCERATION
General Health
![]()
PARENTAL NEGLECT, FAMILY DISSOLUTION, ABUSE, MENTAL RETARDATION,
AND
LEARNING DISORDERS
![]()
RISK BEHAVIORS ASSOCIATED WITH LEGAL PROBLEMS
![]()
CONDITIONS ACQUIRED WITHIN THE INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT
![]()
FINANCING CORRECTIONAL HEALTH CARE SERVICES
![]()
HEALTH CARE STANDARDS
THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS RESPONSE
AND THE NATIONAL COMMISSION ON CORRECTIONAL HEALTH CARE
![]()
RECOMMENDATIONS
Top
Abstract
Recommendation
References
Committee on Adolescence, 2000-2001
David W. Kaplan, MD, MPH, Chairperson
Ronald A. Feinstein, MD
Martin M. Fisher, MD
Jonathan D. Klein, MD, MPH
Luis F. Olmedo, MD
Ellen S. Rome, MD, MPH
W. Samuel Yancy, MD
Liaisons
Paula J. Adams Hillard, MD
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
Diane Sacks, MD
Canadian Pediatric Society
Glen Pearson, MD
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
Section Liaisons
Barbara L. Frankowski, MD, MPH
Section on School Health
Staff
Tammy Piazza Hurley
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The recommendations in this statement do not indicate an exclusive course of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations, taking into account individual circumstances, may be appropriate.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
United States,
January-December 2001.
Pediatrics
2001;
107:202-204 This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
L. S. McReynolds, G. A. Wasserman, R. E. DeComo, R. John, J. M. Keating, and S. Nolen Psychiatric Disorder in a Juvenile Assessment Center Crime Delinquency, April 1, 2008; 54(2): 313 - 334. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Golzari, S. J. Hunt, and L. J. Chamberlain Role of Pediatricians as Advocates for Incarcerated Youth Pediatrics, February 1, 2008; 121(2): e397 - e398. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. A. Gallagher and A. Dobrin Can Juvenile Justice Detention Facilities Meet the Call of the American Academy of Pediatrics and National Commission on Correctional Health Care? A National Analysis of Current Practices Pediatrics, April 1, 2007; 119(4): e991 - e1001. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. Feinstein, R. Gomez, S. Gordon, K. Cruise, and D. DePrato Prevalence of Overweight Youth Among a Population of Incarcerated Juveniles Journal of Correctional Health Care, January 1, 2007; 13(1): 39 - 44. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. L. Cropsey, H. K. Wexler, G. Melnick, F. S. Taxman, and D. W. Young Specialized Prisons and Services: Results From a National Survey. The Prison Journal, January 1, 2007; 87: 58 - 85. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Rosengard, L. A. R. Stein, N. P. Barnett, P. M. Monti, C. Golembeske, and R. Lebeau-Craven Co-Occurring Sexual Risk and Substance Use Behaviors Among Incarcerated Adolescents Journal of Correctional Health Care, October 1, 2006; 12(4): 279 - 287. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Hepatitis and Youth in Corrections Settings Red Book, January 1, 2006; 2006(1): 177 - 178. [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. Gupta, K. J. Kelleher, K. Pajer, J. Stevens, and A. Cuellar Delinquent Youth in Corrections: Medicaid and Reentry Into the Community Pediatrics, April 1, 2005; 115(4): 1077 - 1083. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. A. Spooner, E. M. Gotlieb, and the Steering Committee on Clinical Information Tec Telemedicine: Pediatric Applications Pediatrics, June 1, 2004; 113(6): e639 - e643. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
N. Freudenberg Community Health Services for Returning Jail and Prison Inmates Journal of Correctional Health Care, April 1, 2004; 10(3): 369 - 397. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Hepatitis and Youth in Corrections Settings Red Book, January 1, 2003; 2003(1): 167 - 173. [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
S. Berman Throw-away kids' need medical, mental health services, too AAP News, May 1, 2001; 18(5): 202 - 202. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | E-MAIL ALERTS | SEARCH |